The “very complicated logistics” of justice in the North
An exploration of the justice system in remote northern communities, with 2026 CBA-LCC journalism fellow Erik Pindera
Connectez-vous pour écouter l'article
What does justice look like in remote northern communities, where court arrives on a small plane, weather permitting? And what distinct approaches are Indigenous communities developing to suit their logistical and cultural realities?
Earlier this year, Winnipeg Free Press reporter Erik Pindera used a grant from the Canadian Bar Association and the Law Commission of Canada to fly along and find out. He joins the pod to share what he learned and preview his four-part series, which is due to run in the Free Press in the coming weeks.
Valued at $40 000, the annual CBA-LCC Journalism Fellowship supports the creation of in-depth reporting in print or online media focused on how the law affects Canadians’ lives. Applications for next year’s fellowship are being accepted until December 4, 2026.
The host for this episode is Lisa Taylor, a lawyer and professor of journalism at the University of King’s College in Halifax.
Verdicts & Voices is a legal current affairs podcast presented by the Canadian Bar Association. Views expressed are not necessarily those of the CBA.
Transcript
Hello everyone and welcome to Verdicts & Voices, the Canadian Bar Association's Legal Affairs Podcast. My name is Lisa Taylor. I'm a lawyer and professor of journalism at the University of King's College in Halifax.
Like any journalist who spent time covering law and justice issues, I can tell you you can learn a lot sitting in the cheap seats in the courtroom. And that's true of my guest this week. Erik Pindera is a journalist with the Winnipeg Free Press. Erik reports on law and justice issues, so he knows the courts beat well.
But over the past few months, Erik has been reporting on a part of Manitoba's justice system that he's never before had a chance to observe. The province's Northern Circuit Courts, which bring judges, lawyers, and others into remote northern communities. It's part of the justice system that few lawyers and few people in the South generally ever get to see. Erik was able to undertake his reporting after being awarded the 2026 Law Commission of Canada-Canadian Bar Association Journalism Fellowship. Erik, hello and welcome to the podcast.
Erik Pindera
Hello, Lisa. It’s great to be here.
Lisa
Okay, you've covered Manitoba's justice system for years. What made you want to turn your attention and this sustained reporting opportunity to Northern Circuit Courts?
Erik Pindera
Well, it's a part of the system that I was tangentially aware of but that really had never gotten any experience with. I mean, from reporting out of Winnipeg, occasionally I'd listen to recorded hearings from circuit courts or hear them referenced in written decisions, et cetera. And I was aware that this was a massive part of the system that really doesn't get very much attention from at the very least the public. I mean, it's certainly something the courts and justice officials and government pay a lot of attention to. But the public really does not really have any idea of what it entails, I suppose. And I thought that with this fellowship opportunity, I would be able to get a closer look at that and tell the public about it.
Lisa
Okay, Erik, so if I'm a judge or counsel assigned to circuit court, how does the day begin? Tell me about a typical day.
Erik Pindera
Well, it depends on whether it's a drive-in circuit court or a fly-in court. My focus in this series has been in fly-in courts, which are in remote First Nations throughout Manitoba, largely in the north and northeast, where there's not much of a road network. So a day would typically begin early, around 8 a.m., at a charter air terminal at Winnipeg's international airport where the judge is typically already in discussions with the pilot about whether the plane will actually be able to take off that day. With some frequency they aren't, because of, typically, weather issues either in or near Winnipeg or in the communities where they're going to fly, that are hundreds of kilometres away and have typically relatively short gravel airstrips, particularly susceptible to changes in weather, whether planes can land and take off or not.
So that's how it starts. The judge, typically a number of defence lawyers, a Crown prosecutor, a victim services worker, sometimes some sheriff's officers, all load up onto a relatively small jet, typically a 10-seater, including the pilot seats, and get up in the air and ideally land in whatever community they're heading to in the next hour or so. Sometimes there's issues with that even in the air. I was going up to Little Grand Rapids First Nation in late August this year and while we were in the air, the pilot turned to the judge and said, hey, there's an issue because in Little Grand Rapids there's a secondary transportation from the airport, which is a little bit of a way away from the community proper, somewhat across a lake.
And typically the government has a contract with a helicopter service company to have the court party brought over from the airport by helicopter to the community proper. The pilot advised the judge the helicopter wasn't able to take off from the location where it's typically stationed. So the court party was gonna end up stranded, essentially, at the airport. And the judge said, I mean, if we can't figure out transportation, we're gonna have to just turn the plane around. The judge thankfully has been around a while and asked the pilot to contact the court's air circuit coordinator to contact the local RCMP detachment to ask them if they could do a favour and spare a couple of Mounties and boats to boat over from the community proper to the airport, pick up the court party and boat them back to the community. That was a bit up in the air, so to speak, for about 10 minutes, and then eventually the pilot's dispatcher called back to advise that the RCMP could do a favour and court could go on that day. But I think it's pretty emblematic of the very complicated logistics of these circuit courts in particularly remote places.
Lisa
So you have very short time on the ground on a given day because of the realities of travel. But I'm wondering about other things that might be kind of in short supply on the ground. You talk about the judge, lawyers on both sides, maybe sheriff's deputies if they're transporting an incarcerated person. But when it comes to the supports and services that we kind of expect to be wraparounds relative to the court process, here in the South, the types of solutions that address things like poverty, addiction, lack of housing, just general affordability and welfare issues, are those services provided in any meaningful ways to kind of support the work of circuit courts?
Erik Pindera
Generally speaking, no, or at least not to the extent that they are elsewhere. And I don't wanna paint all communities with the same brush, but generally speaking, there's a lack of robust health services, mental health and addiction services, that sort of thing that are tertiary to the justice system. But also probation officers for the most part aren't coming into remote communities and running programming, for example. That's often left to essentially local restorative justice officials or officials from First Nations organizations, of which First Nations are part of, to kind of fill that gap. There's a big lack in the sort of support services that are available and offered in major centres. Whether that's things like domestic violence programming or anger management, which are pretty frequently offered in major centres in Canada South by probation officials, for example.
That's farther and fewer between in remote First Nations. And again, sometimes those services are offered, but it's in a bit more of an ad hoc way or via different organizations than government. It's often First Nations government related or community run.
Lisa
Your reporting has revealed to me a system where it looks like there are loads of really well-intentioned efforts to take the system of the South and apply it in the North. But you effectively and really eloquently point out differences in which we're talking about two different worlds. I mean you've observed that perhaps our relationship with the police is different when we know that if we call the police they actually have to get on a flight to come to our community. Or it's hard to check in with my probation officer if I don't have a landline and there is no cell service. I mean, to what extent is this system able to be effectively applied to such a very different geography?
Erik Pindera
I don't think it can be effectively applied. To some degree it can. But I think, and this is something that the officials I've spoken to, both in the judiciary here but also in First Nations organizations and government, recognize, I think this is gonna have to be conducted differently if people who live in these remote communities are going to be given justice. And that's both from the perspective of victim and offender, I think. These communities are very different places with different cultural norms than much of the South, right? And there's different ideas of... in certain cases, to be clear, but there's different ideas of how justice should look, how it should be performed, how involved the community should be in the justice process. That's less of a Western extractive form of justice in which someone does something wrong, it's prosecuted in a court of law and they're removed from the community, put in a jail or prison for X amount of time, placed on conditions.
I think particularly when we're talking about more, for lack of a better word, minor offending, first time offending, there is a real focus now, I mean there's been a focus for some time here, across the country, but also particularly in Manitoba, on restorative justice. But it seems to be, over the last couple of years, has become a major focus of both the government and the courts, but of First Nations themselves and organizations they represent, to move toward restorative justice programming for a lot of offending in these communities, or to divert certain offences to restorative justice programs in a lot of these communities and to involve Indigenous concepts of justice in the functioning of the Western system, I suppose, as opposed to having two separate systems. The goal seems to be to integrate them into one system, working more collaboratively than just that extractive form of justice, I suppose.
Lisa
And as you say, in Manitoba and elsewhere in the country, there are certainly bold statements being made in that direction, to give Indigenous communities more input into how justice is conceptualized and how it's delivered. What signs of progress, if any, did you see during your time on the ground?
Erik Pindera
I mean, even just seeing on the most base level, seeing a Crown and a number of defence lawyers going through a docket and a restorative justice worker from a community sitting there in court, updating officials there about, okay, this person who's on the docket has been doing XYZ programming with us, they will continue. They're successful at this point. Or this person is not participating, we have to revert this back to the regular court process. But just seeing that, how frequent it was, the number of people on a given docket who are going through restorative justice programming was somewhat eye-opening. You see a lot more of it on those dockets than you do on dockets down south, in my experience at least. So that alone was an interesting thing to see.
But also in Manitoba there's been a couple of pretty major initiatives this year. One of them is essentially setting up a community court in Opaskwayak Cree Nation, which is, by Manitoba terms, not a remote place at all. It's accessible by the road network and by rail, and it's directly adjacent to The Pas, which is a northern town. It's an interesting place, OCN. But officials at OCN, for quite a while, have been working with the provincial government and the courts to essentially allow them to have a circuit. It's essentially a community court that operates within the community, rather than having offenders from OCN going over to The Pas, which is directly adjacent to the First Nation. It's across the river. To have their day in provincial court. And the goal there is, it's essentially being run with a provincial court judge, but also restorative justice officials from the community, elders, et cetera.
And the idea is that everyone who's going through that court, in the long term, with approvals from those officials and the judge, will be going through restorative justice programming. And if successful, they'll have their charges diverted and stayed typically. Anyone who's not successful will be essentially told to go back to court in The Pas. And certain charges certainly will be heard in that court. I mean, for example, first degree murder is not gonna be sent to a restorative justice process, right? But the overall goal, from what the official at OCN who's been spearheading their restorative justice program says, is to keep people out of the system long term. It's particularly for first time offenders and more minor offenders, to keep them out of the cycle of offending, to get them healthier, to get their families healthier, to get them involved in their community and trying to address their wrongdoing with the community in mind. That alone is very interesting.
And so essentially the provincial government approved that over the summer and it's supposed to begin sitting soon. I'm not a hundred percent sure if it actually has begun sitting yet. I think there was some delay, but it's approved and it's gonna begin sitting in the community itself. And that was somewhat historic, this agreement that was signed between the government and OCN's government to allow this court to be set up. Another thing that the provincial government slash the provincial courts have done was name an associate chief judge of the provincial court for reconciliation. Her name is Jerilee Ryle. She's a First Nations woman herself, was named a judge of the provincial court last year, and then was named an ACJ this summer. And it seems to me, her... well, beyond the obvious, trying to work on reconciliation between the courts and First Nations and Indigenous people more broadly, the way she describes it to me is listening to what First Nations need and want from the courts.
And a significant amount of what, particularly I think, early in her term as the ACJ, is examining how well the circuit courts are functioning, and how they aren't, and trying to determine what the court can do to... I mean, provide better access to justice in remote communities, remote First Nations communities.
Lisa
Governments come up against the best of intentions, because I realized that shortly after you completed your reporting, or as you were just wrapping up, the provincial court chief judge announced a cut to circuit court sittings, dropping to 108 annual sittings from 176. What did you think when you heard that news?
Erik Pindera
I was not overly surprised, to be honest. And I mean, I'll say this, the chief judge of Manitoba's provincial court, he is not one to pay lip service to this issue, to reconciliation, to access to justice in remote communities. He himself has visited many of these communities throughout his term. But he does not control the court's budget. He controls the amount of money the court is given, but it's not up to him to determine how much money the court is actually getting from the provincial government. And in his estimation the provincial court would need several more judges to be able to continue with the number of circuit court sittings it had prior to this announcement. So I mean I think it's this rock and a hard place. I think a lot of judges and other people in the system think that the provincial government here in Manitoba is quite keen on changing things, but are not necessarily prepared to fund all those changes, I suppose. And that's not to say they don't put any money toward anything. But it seems to me that there's some concern about how much the government will put the money where its mouth is, so to speak.
Lisa
Now, after the time you've spent traveling to circuit courts with the key players and speaking to people involved, and I should make clear, this is not an issue just for Manitoba. You're focusing on Manitoba, but this is an issue for northern courts that other jurisdictions have responsibility for. But what do you want your readers across Canada to most understand about the realities of access to justice in northern Canada?
Erik Pindera
I want to preface this by saying I think that everyone involved in the justice system is trying their utmost best to provide access to justice in these communities. It's not to say there aren't failings in certain cases, et cetera, but I think overall people are really, really trying to provide the service that should be provided, that the justice system says should be provided to offender, to victim, to community. But that it's not. These communities are not being given access to justice in the way that communities in the South are. Even under-resourced communities, small communities in the South, have much better access to justice than these remote communities in the north. Both remote First Nations and northern communities more broadly. They just do not have the same access to justice. And I think that's what I want the readers to take away, that these communities are being underserved and are not getting justice in the way that our society, our system says they should.
Lisa
Well, if that is your goal, I will say you have achieved it, as someone who's gotten an early look at the series. It's poignant and it's really stirring, this reminder that the system on a good day in the north is still light years behind what can be offered elsewhere and that there's an inequity there to be resolved. Erik, thank you so much for your excellent reporting and for joining me on the podcast.
Erik Pindera
Thank you, Lisa. Thanks for having me. It's been a pleasure to talk about it.
Lisa
Erik Pindera's series Northern Justice will run in the Winnipeg Free Press starting on Saturday, November 21 and on three consecutive Saturdays that follow. His work will also be published in the CBA's National magazine in the coming weeks. The fellowship that allowed Erik to undertake this reporting is accepting applications once again. The Law Commission of Canada and the Canadian Bar Association's Journalism Fellowship is valued at $40,000. It supports the creation of in-depth reporting projects that focus on how the law impacts people's lives. There's a link for the call for applications in the show notes.
That's the podcast for this week. I'm Lisa Taylor. Thanks for joining us.